After Carrie Underwood's surprise announcement last week that her next album, Storyteller will hit stores October 23rd, fans are now anxiously awaiting another big reveal: the likely massive tour in support of the project. Even just five albums into her career, the country superstar could fill a whole show with nothing but Number One hits, but if history repeats, she'll throw in other fan favorites that were never released to radio — but easily could've been chart-dominators if they had been. In celebration of Storyteller, we asked readers which of Underwood's deep cuts are their favorites, and the number of votes you cast set an all-time Rolling Stone Country record. Here are the results.