Worst: Ace Young Proposes to Diana DeGarmo, Season 11
Sorry all you hopeless romantics, but this American Idol marriage proposal was anything but romantic. Instead, when Season 5 finalist Ace Young asked Season 3 runner-up Diana DeGarmo to marry him (during Season 11, no less), it seemed a little too staged. "With the help of David Webb Jewelry, I have a way of making this last forever," said Young, before getting down on one knee. DeGarmo, of course, said yes — making sure to dramatically mouth the word so that everyone could see her response. Still, the two seemed genuinely happy, and they married a year later.