.
Lulu

Lou Reed and Metallica

Lulu

Warner Bros.
Rolling Stone: star rating
5 3
Community: star rating
81
November 1, 2011

When Lou Reed and Metallica walked the wild side together at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame anniversary concert in 2009, it seemed like a one-off jam session. But two years later, they've joined forces for a collaboration that's less ridiculous than you might expect. Metallica are prog-metal maximists at heart, but on Lulu, they meet Reed halfway, often favoring the high-decibel droning the Velvet Underground learned from avant-minimalist composers: repetition, atonal overtones, traffic-jam audio vérité. 

Both acts have had a thing for long songs; here, three tracks stretch past 11 minutes. Marathons like "Dragon" buzz gorgeously, emphasizing power-jangle guitars or 69-year-old Reed's Continuum Fingerboard. Things can get ponderous once Metallica start impatiently stomping, but often they turn Reed's pretensions into something muscular.

The art-song cycle – originally written for a Berlin theater production, declaimed from a female protagonist's POV – revels in dominatrix decadence and bodily fluids ("a bleeding strap across my back . . ."); 44 years after "Venus in Furs," the words won't shock anybody, though they try. Reed's reading is flat enough to get subsumed in the drone. He's still preferable to the Cookie Monster vomit that passes for vocals on many metal records – and he's still his own rock & roll animal.

Listen to "The View":

Related
Video: Lou Reed and Metallica on the Making of 'Lulu'

prev
Album Review Main Next

ADD A COMMENT

Community Guidelines »
loading comments

loading comments...

COMMENTS

Sort by:
    Read More

    Music Reviews

    more Reviews »
    Stay Connected

    Sign up to get Rolling Stone's daily newsletter.

    Song Stories

    “IRM”

    Charlotte Gainsbourg | 2009

    Fashioned to mimic the sound of a magnetic resonance imaging or MRI, "IRM" (the French designation for the brain scan) grew out of Gainsbourg’s love of the sound of the clickety-clack of medical machinery. The IRM album project also marked the fulfillment of two goals for the singer: to document a traumatic experience, and to record an album with Beck. Though her co-creator and producer didn’t necessarily know the details of her water-skiing accident and resulting cerebral hemorrhage (which lead to the IRM of the song's title), he somehow knew how to handle the material. "Beck had a way of guessing what I was thinking and feeling without me telling him," said Gainsbourg. "We never discussed these things explicitly."

    More Song Stories entries »