Rob Roy

Jessica Lange

Directed by Michael Caton-Jones
Rolling Stone: star rating
5 0
Community: star rating
5 0 0
December 19, 2000

"Rob Roy," set against the swash-buckling backgroung of clans battling nobles in 18th-century Scotland, is really a love story between a man and his wife, according to Scottish director Michael Caton-Jones (Scandal, This Boy's Life). Believe that if you want. Jessica Lange brings uncommon emotional intensity to the role of Mary, Mrs. to the heroic Robert Roy MacGregor (Liam Neeson) and mother of his two sons. Lange and Neeson put genuine erotic heat into their love scenes, and Mary back-talks Rob with 20th-century feminist fire when he's being a jerk. But it's only when he gets down to the business of battle that Rob and the film really smolder.

Top dog among the do-badders is Tim Roth as Cunningham, a perfumed aristocrat in the evil service of the Marquis of Montrose (a smarmy John Hurt). Screenwriter Alan Sharp, another Scot, lays in a lot of history, which is, in a word, dreary. Roth is not. Flamboyant doesn't begin to describe his wickedly entertaining performance. Cunningham comes on as a fop — the way Brando's Mr. Christian did in Mutiny on the Bounty — but there's a precision killer and cocksman under the powder and wigs. Cunningham must have the highest sperm count in the Highlands. He beds the Marquis' maid Betty (Vicki Masson), she's pregnant. He rapes Mary, and despite her attempt to wash out his malevolent seed in the loch, she's pregnant. That leads to a duel to the death.

Doesn't it always? That's the trouble with Rob Roy: You always know where it's going even as it meanders for two and a half hours getting there. Compensation comes in gorgeous cinematography by Karl Walter Lindenlaub that lets you drink in the mist in the gloaming and the heather on the hill. But Rob Roy isn't Brigadoon. Rob Roy's story stands or falls with the appeal of its protagonist. Though you might question casting an Irishman as a Scot, Neeson makes a stalwart, sexy hero — even in a kilt. Unfortunately, the script saddles him with virtuous speeches ("I don't want to see a child hungry or old folks cold") that make him sound like he's running for office or sainthood. Only when Roth the rogue brings out the bad boy in Neeson the Highlander does Rob Roy cut it as a rousing adventure.

Movie Review Main Next


Community Guidelines »
loading comments

loading comments...


Sort by:
    Read More

    Movie Reviews

    • joe Nicolas Cage
      star rating
      Roadside Attractions
    • star rating
      Summit Entertainment
    • star rating
      Paramount Pictures
    More Reviews »
    Daily Newsletter

    Get the latest RS news in your inbox.

    Sign up to receive the Rolling Stone newsletter and special offers from RS and its
    marketing partners.


    We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Rolling Stone and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

    Song Stories


    Tune-Yards | 2011

    The opening track to Merrill Garbus’ second album under the Tune-Yards banner (she also plays in the trio Sister Suvi), “Bizness” is a song about relationships that is as colorful as the face paint favored by Garbus both live and in her videos. Disjointed funk bass, skittering African beats, diced-and-sliced horns and Garbus’ dynamic voice, which ranges from playful coos to throat-shredding howls, make “Bizness” reminiscent of another creative medium. “I'd like for them not to be songs as much as quilts or collages or something,” Garbus said.

    More Song Stories entries »