River Phoenix, Lili Taylor, Richard Panebianco

Directed by Nancy Savoca
Rolling Stone: star rating
5 0
Community: star rating
5 0 0
October 4, 1991

Beefed up and buzz-cut to play a 1963 marine partying hard in San Francisco before getting shipped overseas, River Phoenix busts out of his usual sensitive mode (Running on Empty, Stand by Me) to deliver a performance of blunt intensity. In the early scenes of Dogfight, it looks as if he'd found a movie to match. Written by Bob Comfort, a former marine, and directed by Nancy Savoca, who debuted with the gritty True Love in 1989, Dogfight has a provocative premise. The 4 B's – Birdlace (Phoenix), Berzin (Richard Panebianco), Benjamin (Mitchell Whitfield) and Buele (Anthony Clark) – join up with their foulmouthed, beer-swilling, casually cruel buddies to organize a dogfight. It's a contest in which each soldier bets fifty dollars that he can show up at a party with the butt-ugliest girl.

Birdlace latches on to Rose (Lili Taylor), a gawky waitress whom he finds practicing guitar at a cafe owned by her mother (Holly Near). Among the other contestants are a towering Indian woman, Ruth Two Bears (Sue Morales), and the toothless Marcy (E.G. Daily), a hooker Berzin has hired to charm the judges by showing up without her false teeth. Accidentally, Rose finds out that she and the other women are being used. Overcoming her shyness, she lashes out at Birdlace for entrapping her in this sadistic game.

Comfort is trying to show the parallels between these disdained women and the marines, who are ridiculed by many civilians as subhuman warmongers. Feeling rejected, they want to do some rejecting, too. But Comfort fails to cut deep enough to draw blood. Taylor is a fine actress (Mystic Pizza, Say Anything), but even teased hair, bad makeup and a little extra weight (she gained twelve pounds) do not make her dogfight material. Comfort conceived Rose as a fat woman. Cast accordingly, the character might have been more powerful and moving.

Feeling guilty, Birdlace follows Rose home and requests a real date. They go to a fancy restaurant and then to a coffee house where Rose sings "What Have They Done to the Rain" to her soldier boy's appreciative audience of one. Later, in Rose's bedroom, they make love.

For contrast, we watch the other B's getting tattooed and then buying blow jobs from a hooker in a movie theater. She replaces her gum between each man. Nice touch. It's the kind of thing you expect from Savoca, who raised True Love above the hackneyed by keeping her Bronx lovers in keen touch with reality. But Savoca didn't write the script this time. On someone else's turf, she's nowhere near as comfortable.

The script sends Birdlace off to Vietnam, where his eyes are opened by combat and grievous personal loss. Returning to San Francisco in 1967, the summer of love, he can reach out to Rose as a wiser man. These scenes are sweet, wonderfully acted and totally bogus. Dogfight doesn't sum up an era; it merely romanticizes it. What could have been an incisive movie about alienation deteriorates into a conventional romance.

Movie Review Main Next


Community Guidelines »
loading comments

loading comments...


Sort by:
    Read More

    Movie Reviews

    More Reviews »
    Around the Web
    Powered By ZergNet
    Daily Newsletter

    Get the latest RS news in your inbox.

    Sign up to receive the Rolling Stone newsletter and special offers from RS and its
    marketing partners.


    We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Rolling Stone and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

    Song Stories


    The Commodores | 1984

    The year after soul legends Marvin Gaye and Jackie Wilson died, songwriter Dennis Lambert asked members of the Commodores to give him a tape of ideas. "And the one from Walter Orange has this wonderful bass line," said co-writer Franne Golde. "Plus the lyric, 'Marvin, he was a friend of mine' ... Within 10 minutes, we had decided it should be something like a modern R&B version of 'Rock 'n' Roll Heaven,' and I just said, 'Nightshift.'" This tribute to the recently deceased musicians was the band's only hit without Lionel Richie, who had left for a solo career.

    More Song Stories entries »