Steven Tyler made no secret of his affection for the ladies during his time as an Idol judge. Charming at times, his conduct could also border on creepy. Take his interaction with the family of Season 11 contestant Shannon Magrane. After the judges found out the then-15-year-old's father was a professional baseball player, they invited her entire clan into the audition room. All was going well until Tyler opened his mouth to Papa Magrane, describing the man's teenage daughter as "hot, humid and happening." Cue awkward silence.