The Winners and Losers of 'American Idol'

Who? Rock-worshiping Season One contestant.

Peak: iTunes-only single "My Religion" sold like the 2004 equivalent of hotcakes, eventually hitting Number One on Billboard's Hot Digital Songs chart.

Low: An unflattering season of The Surreal Life, where she tirelessly made reference to how Idol tried to downplay her rocker personality, and a subsequent short run on Fox’s Gimme My Reality Show that she later called a personal regret as big as doing Idol.

Currently: Starr is laying low, doing charity work in Los Angeles.