1964 Tokyo Games, 1968 Mexico City Games
Medal count: Five golds, two silver
At 18, freestyle swimmer Schollander won golds in the 100 meter, 400 meter, 4x100 and 4x200. Four years later, he won another gold as part of the 4x200 team, and came in second in the 200 meter in its first year as an Olympic event. Between those Games, he won three NCAA championships at Yale, where he was a member of the Skull and Bones society alongside George W. Bush.