3. Tie: Mark Spitz (Munich 1972) and Michael Phelps (Bejing 2008)
In the cases of swimmers Mark Spitz and Michael Phelps, you can never have enough gold medals. At the Munich Olympics in 1972, Spitz (and his studly 'stache) would win a total of seven gold medals. Thirty-six years later, at the 2008 Bejing Games, Phelps (and his studly six pack) would top Spitz's mark, by earning a total of eight gold medals: 100m butterfly, 200m butterfly, 200m freestyle, 200m individual medley, 400m individual medley, 4×100m freestyle relay, 4×200m freestyle relay and 4×100m medley relay.