The Travers Take

Newer Older Latest

At The Movies With Peter Travers: "Star Trek"

May 7, 2009 5:33 PM

This week, Peter Travers boldly goes where all critics are soon headed: the new Star Trek movie. There have been 10 ST films and many iterations of the TV show, which could lead to Trek fatigue — but Lost's J.J. Abrams has made something spectacular: the summer blockbuster Wolverine should have been. The movie is an origin story that tracks James T. Kirk (Chris Pine) and Mr. Spock (Zachary Quinto) as they are just starting their careers. Winona Ryder is solid as Spock's human mother (OMFG, says Travers about the casting), but Pine and Quinto are standouts. And Quinto manages to utter "Live long and prosper" as a "screw-you salute." The plot was penned by the writers of Transformers, and the casting and look of the film work well. Ultimately, the film allows fans to look at all the characters again for the first time, finding new life in them. And Travers was even touched by a moment of true friendship in the film — "If you can get moved by a movie that's filled with explosions, something is being done right," he says.

So what's the trick to learning the Vulcan salute? Quinto gave Travers a few tips.

Evidently the left-handed Quinto, like Travers, had trouble with the finger-bending sign, and spent some time with his digits rubber-banded together. Pharrell would be impressed with the results.

As for the Scum Bucket, Peter returns to the 10 Star Trek films in search of the worst. The offender: Star Trek V: The Final Frontier starring and directed by William Shatner. In the film, Shatner's pomposity is in full flower and the move is so awful, "Windbags at Warped Speed" was Travers' original headline when he reviewed the film. Shatner actually sent a note back that said, "Fuck you, Bill Shatner" which Travers now has framed in his home. The movie is still Scum Bucket material, though.

Read Travers' full Star Trek review here: Star Trek.


Newer Older Latest

11 Comments


Michael | November 13, 2009 11:21 AM

The review synopsis on this page has it wrong. I don't think Travers thinks Ryder is solid at all. If you read his interview, he's saying OMFG to the casting, and nowhere does he say her casting was solid. Get it right there, guys. And I agree with him on that point. For me, it's the only taint to this fantastic film.

Ben | May 12, 2009 5:11 AM

Stuart: In the movie Spock IS already serving on the Enterprise. Kirk and Spock don't start their careers at the same time. Take a chill pill.

JP | May 11, 2009 6:16 PM

I'm having a hard time raving about this movie like everyone else. It's really good. Yet, it's an origin story. It just feels like it was setting up something that they didn't deliver in this movie.

Despite that, it was well acted with great special effects and action scenes. Maybe too many references to the classic series. After a while, it started to feel like a drinking game. It's tied with "X-Men Origins: Wolverine" as an entertaining two hours to spend in a theater.

Scooter Korvette | May 10, 2009 3:08 PM

I agree, the film was pretty damn wonderful. This most probably will be the best movie of the summer, though there will be a few other good ones.


Rich | May 9, 2009 9:26 PM

Stuart,

New timeline. Anything is possible. The future is completely different. Vulcan is gone. Where will spock go for Pon Far?

Kim | May 8, 2009 10:35 PM

Just got home from the theater and I loved it. They didn't rehash the old Star Trek stuff they but they did stay true to the characters. WoW

Phil | May 8, 2009 9:07 PM

I give it 4.9 out of 5 popcorn kernals popped. Terrific movie. What makes it so fantastic is that they did not tamper with the tried and true. Updated? Yes and well...no. Reimanged? THANK VULCANS NO!

Brekke | May 8, 2009 7:44 PM

Just got home from the movie.. Phenomenal!

Lois | May 8, 2009 6:42 PM

Stuart - haven't seen it yet but Captain Pike figures in the movie. I'm an original Trek fan and I've been dreading this...but I'll give it a shot.

Stuart | May 8, 2009 5:48 PM

I hope Mr. Abrams can explain how its possible that Mr. Spock and J.T. Kirk started their careers at Star Fleet together when Spock was already on the Enterprise serving under Capt. Pike!!!!

Jonathan | May 7, 2009 10:23 PM

DR Spock? He's the baby doctor from the 1960's.

Unless this re-imagined Star Trek has Spock with a PHD, I believe it should be Mr. Spock.

Leave a comment



Advertisement

Advertisement