The Travers Take

Newer Older Latest

At The Movies With Peter Travers: "State of Play" and "17 Again"

April 16, 2009 7:15 PM

Despite the fact that it's been slashed down from a six-hour British miniseries to a two-hour Hollywood suspense film, Peter Travers recommends moviegoers check out the "gripping" State of Play this week. The film stars Russell Crowe as a reporter investigating the suspicious death of his best friend's mistress (the pal is a politician played by Ben Affleck). "From this sex scandal unravels every kind of possible conniving horror that could go on in the world we all live in," Travers says. Directed by The Last King of Scotland helmer Kevin MacDonald, Travers also liked how the film is "a movie in love with the newspaper business."

And then there's the Scum Bucket: Peter Travers doesn't hate Zac Efron, it's movies starring Zac Efron that Travers can't stand, and that includes all three of the High School Musicals.

This week's Bucket-bound film is 17 Again, starring Friends actor Matthew Perry as a miserable 37-year-old man with two kids and an unhappy marriage who meets a magical school janitor that turns him "17 again," thus transforming him into Zac Efron. It's like Tom Hanks in Big in reverse, except much worse. It's feeble, delving into cliché jokes and just plain creepy when Perry/Efron's daughter falls in love with 17-year-old Perry/Efron. Similar to Back to the Future when Lea Thompson's character was crushing on her son Michael J. Fox in reverse, and again, much worse. To quote Travers, "This is a movie that the Scum Bucket was invented for."

Based on its trailer alone, Travers would love to put the Beyoncé home invasion flick Obsessed into the Scum Bucket, but because of your e-mails — and because the studio wouldn't screen the film for critics — Travers will shell out his own cash to watch what's sure to be an absolute dud. Be sure to check back next week and follow along to Travers' Twitter to see if Obsessed surpassed his low, low expectations.

Read Travers' reviews here:
State of Play
17 Again
Is Anybody There?
Every Little Step

>>Watch every episode of our weekly Peter Travers video podcast by subscribing via iTunes (when prompted, click “Launch application”). Every Friday, a new episode will be delivered to your iTunes. [If you don’t have iTunes, download it here.]


Newer Older Latest

8 Comments


teodora | May 1, 2009 3:53 AM

the 17 again is the best movie in the world.

Ceeci | April 20, 2009 5:39 PM

(17 Again & BTTF)Wow, Zac's daughter falls for him just like when Michael's mom did too! HAHA! I saw the 2 movies and both Michael's mom and Zac's daughter were liteary trying to sudiuce them! I laughed at those scences... hard! But thats not the only stuff they have in common.

Americana | April 17, 2009 5:17 PM

Didn't they already do this 'older guy is young again' in 1987?!! Why bring this contrived plot device back and by the way 37 HA! More like 43 who does Perry think he's kidding?! And for you Beyonce hating bitches "Don't Mess with Zohan" was pure grade A crap on a stick and so was the last Sandra Bullock movie in fact a LOT of Hollywood 'stars' are turning out junk after junk so piss off haters!!

Art | April 17, 2009 10:52 AM

Ok negative nancy!

Mariel! | April 17, 2009 10:17 AM

I want to watch that Beyonce movie. It looks great. I hope you don't add it to the scum bucket...but we know you are a bit hard headed. Oh well.

PS I subscribed to you on iTunes that is really cool. :)

Art | April 17, 2009 9:37 AM

Thank you Peter for stating the obvious. I think the Beyonce film will be great...but whatever you only like depressing films right?

Poor Zac he never stood a chance did he?

If only there were fair reviewers that saw movies without pre conceived judgements. Why can't you just go into a film and see it without putting it into the scum bucket before viewing it or by just watching the trailer. Thanks Peter!

Bo | April 17, 2009 2:41 AM

Dear Peter Travers, you never address the issue of the target group. I don't think 17 Again and Hannah Montana were made for just everyone. Isn't it obvious you will trash it?

So Zac Efron gets attracted to her daughter in 17 again. It was similar in Back to the Future where Michael J. Fox gets attracted to her younger mother. That was pretty funny.

liz | April 16, 2009 10:27 PM

That Beyonce flick looks really awful.
I hope they pay you well at RS.

Leave a comment



Advertisement

Advertisement