The Travers Take

Newer Older Latest

"Knowing" and Other Nicolas Cage Box-Office Winners That Don't Deserve to Be Hits

March 23, 2009 5:00 PM

May the worst movie win. Yes, it happened again. On a box-office weekend where the race should have been between the silliness of I Love You, Man with Jason Segel and Paul Rudd and the sophistication of Duplicty with Julia Roberts and Clive Owen, the winner is Knowing! That's right, Knowing, the sanctimonious sci-fi parable starring a hangdog Nicolas Cage in a one-note performance as an astrophysics professor at MIT who learns that the world may be ending and damn soon. With tacky special effects, a scarily done plane crash excepted, Knowing drones on like a sermon that makes you root for the world to end just to put you out of your misery.

And yet Knowing raked in a kickass $24 million as opposed to barely respectable $18 million for I Love You, Man and a deadly $14 million for Duplicity, prompting a Variety headline to shout: "Nic Knocks Julia—Knowing Throttles Roberts' Return." Ouch! Which of the three big movies that opened this weekend do you think deserved to wear the box-office crown? And how about an even more pertinent question: How does Nic Cage do it? Once a powerful actor who delivered astonishing performances in films as diverse as Leaving Las Vegas, Raising Arizona, Moonstruck, Face-Off, Wild At Heart and Adaptation, Cage has been turning out a series of unwatchable flops—you trying staying awake during Captain Corelli's Madolin or The Wicker Man or Bangkok Dangerous.

Even worse are the lousy Cage films that score big at the box-office. I'm not just talking the National Treasure films that are at least fitfully entertaining. I'm talking junk, from Gone in Sixty Seconds to Ghost Rider, that manages to deliver big numbers despite a quality level so low it's barely measurable. Am I wrong? What did you think of Knowing and Cage's acting? What drew you to see Knowing in the first place? What titles represent the best and worst of Nic Cage?


Box Office
Newer Older Latest

21 Comments


Nita | April 26, 2009 6:03 AM

Knowing was by no means perfect but it was one of the most philosophically stimulating movies I've seen in a long time.

Jake | April 8, 2009 1:07 PM

How has no one mentioned Cage's performance in Matchstick Men? That was a great movie. And to Nick V. and others who are pretending Cage has not become a paycheck actor, I hope you're right, but frankly I doubt it. No one's denying his talent, but his recent choices have been clearly focused on money more than content in my opinion. Maybe I'm wrong though and he just likes big blockbusters that depend far more on special effects than plot. The take home here is that we want our H.I. McDunnough back!

Steeve | March 31, 2009 12:57 AM

Oh and i forgot to mention to all of us other people that live outside of the world ,,,, oh i mean The US.
Have you ever noticed that these movies allways destroy everythign in the usa and yeah they call it the end of the world???? lol I dont think since that movie inderpendance day they have showed destruction outside of the usa.
Remember film writers there is actually life outside of the USA...
lol

Steeve | March 31, 2009 12:52 AM

HI there everyone i knwo theres so many other reviews out there for this movie and yeah no one will pobably ever read mine but we just went and saw this movie.
Yeah there is some stunning visual effects such as the plane crash that blow youu away but did anyone else feel pissed when it turned out to be aliens?
I mean who do they get to research their films?
They couldndt even refrence to the bible correctly!
1 corinthians 12 has nothing to do with PROPHETS, WHAT A LOAD!
And WHY aliens? COme on they could of made it better then that crap!
ITs funny there never seems to be many good movies untill the mid time of year and end of year.
Cant wait to see the delayed Star Trek and Terminator
You can allways tell if a movies good by the amount of people who try and copy it to download etc,
Nick cage was ok in acting but yeah they aliens jsut ruined the movie for me
Sorry guys
Cheers
Steve

RN | March 30, 2009 7:58 PM

I saw Knowing tonight and thought it was really good.

Nicolas Cage's acting was excellent - the hurt from the death of his wife leading to his determination to pursue the code.

And the film became really emotional and at times terrifying.

The ending was different but still worked.

And I read somewhere that Nicolas Cage has had 16 movies go to the Number 1 spot on opening. Not many actors can open that consistently so he must have something!

Tim Miller | March 28, 2009 10:58 PM

What's so wrong with just going to a big dumb movie for the fun of it and to be entertained? What the large majority of movie goers actually enjoy and critics usually hate.. Sci fi's always a winner and by it's nature there's always a fair bit of suspension of disbelief required. Seriously does anyone go to these films to watch Actors acting? People deserve a bit of escapism at the moment.
Re Nic Cage. If he was a company I'd like to own shares! Always entertaining, the guy can act and since when did being in box office hits become such a "sin" for critics in the film business. After all "it's just a movie". People involved in the movie business and critics especially take themselves and films generally way too seriously. Make a movie, tell an interesting story and make it entertaining. There's room for all different kinds of films for all tastes and maybe films should be judged by how successful the film makers are in meeting their intentions rather than the amount of money they make. This usually seems to form a judgement of value somehow? Crazy. I guess that's why it's called the film business..

H.I | March 28, 2009 7:24 PM

I BLAME IDIOT AMERICA FOR THE SUCCESS OF NIC CAGE. THEY WANT DUMB SHIT THEY'LL GET DUMB SHIT

travis | March 26, 2009 5:57 PM

What does everyone think of Nicolas Cage in "Bringing Out the Dead" ??

jyj | March 25, 2009 4:45 PM

Cage was spot on in Raising Arizona, still one of the funniest movies ever made, but for god's sake that's really about it. I think Cage has the same agent as Keanu Reeves, both suck, but both still get big time movies somehow.

Ryan DB | March 25, 2009 12:35 PM

Midlife crisis has hit and his career, most likely, is on the downslope. He's probably thinking that he should get in one as many money makers as possible, despite the quality (i.e. the aquamans), and fill his treasure chests before opportunities run out. Sad, but I can't say I wouldn't do the same. Hopefully he makes enough money from these cows that he will start mixing it up with some more challenging performances.

Nick V. | March 25, 2009 11:55 AM

I think Nicolas Cage is a fine actor who has just as many great movies as he does dumb ones...I don't understand why Travers is so hard on him...seriously Peter, you have really become one of those critics who simply lives to snark, which is what hack writers do, and you are above that, as is evident in your writing when you see a truly great movie. I know Nicolas Cage has made some stinkers, and what probably makes it even harder to take is that those stinkers like National Treasure and Ghost Rider go on to make a ton of money, but he has turned in very good performances in some great movies. Anyone who has seen Adaptation(which he should've won the Oscar for), Lord of War, Moonstruck, Peggy Sue Got Married, Leaving Las Vegas, Face/Off, Wild at Heart or even The Rock(the only Michael Bay movie I can somewhat tolerate) can't possibly call him a paycheck actor who ruins movies he is in. Unlike Robert DeNiro and Al Pacino, who seem to have really become paycheck actors, I really feel that Cage is likely to still have some gems in the future.
Travers...listen to the advice of Roger Ebert, a true film critic who reviews a film for the people who would go to see it, and don't be so quick to bash it because it has a big name star, a dumb premise, and will probably make good money. Don't turn into another disposable blogger like Nikki Finke, because we really don't need more of those.

Steve | March 24, 2009 11:11 PM

The Watchmen and Knowing I fell asleep through the first half hour. I wish I could have formed an opinion about either movie.

M.0. | March 24, 2009 6:03 PM

I've never seen Nicholas Cage in a movie he didn't ruin.

Willis Hughes | March 24, 2009 4:34 PM

I Love You, Man was hilarious, but maybe its fault was that people thought it was just another JA like film? I just watched Raising Arizona the other night, and I realized that Cage is pretty much the exact same actor, just with worse scripts! It's a shame I Love You, Man didn't get first, but maybe people just have an innate love for crap this year? We're in a shitty economy and movies are easy entertainment, especially if they make things so bad that we feel good about our lives...Anyways, as bad as Cage's recent films have been, the Wicker Man is so bad it's fucking hilarious! Funniest awful movie I have ever seen that had no intention of being funny.

Eric | March 24, 2009 12:33 PM

I reckon RollingGnome doesn't actually read articles. I believe he waits to see if Travers wrote anything and no matter what the subject, basically repeats the same old crap. RollingGnome commentary = Pointless.

Ryan | March 24, 2009 10:40 AM

For the life of me, I cannot understand why "Knowing" has received such scorn from critics at large. I think it's intellectually stimulating and grip-the-arms-of-your-chair suspenseful. And while Nicolas Cage has churned out his share of howlers in recent years, by no means has his talent diminished. I'd like to use this opportunity to commend one of his most criminally underrated films/performances: "The Weather Man" (NOT to be confused with the admittedly disastrous "Wicker Man"). And "The Weather Man" was released four short years ago. With cage, the good is so good that I'll take it with the bad. That's the risk a truly daring actor takes.

Bo | March 24, 2009 9:49 AM

I haven't seen Knowing yet, it hasn't opened in my cinema, but I will probably wait for DVD anyway, (determinism vs. randomness is an old topic,) and even that's not for sure.

Ten titles with Cage that stimulated me most sorted approximately:

1. Leaving Las Vegas
2. Face/Off
3. Adaptation
4. Lord of War
5. Wild at Heart
6. Con Air
7. Raising Arizona
8. City of Angels
9. The Rock
10. National Treasure

movienut | March 24, 2009 9:30 AM

I've seen Watchmen, Duplicity, and Knowing within the last week. Watchmen left me high and dry, with gratuitous violence/gore which detracted from the semi-plot of the movie and the eventual villain which was about as transparent as a pane of glass. Duplicity, while I enjoyed it, was extremely confusing if you weren't focused in on everything. If you wondered why the poor return from the box office, all you had to do was listen to the comments of the people leaving theater. Word of mouth is the greatest advertisement for a movie, so don't expect Duplicity to pick up in the ratings. Knowing was a bit mind numbing, but I don't go to the movies to be enlightened. It's pure and simple entertainment - which is why 90% of the public goes to movies. I don't discount there are movies that are great testaments to heroic deeds of individuals or groups of people, but if you read the movie's synopsis prior to going, don't feign that you were 'surprised' by the lack of depth - for crying out loud, it's Hollywood - not the New Testament.

Review Reader | March 24, 2009 1:49 AM

I'm sorry Mr. Travers, but have you actually seen "Knowing" yet, or are you still just trashing it based on the previews (you know, like an amateur would do)?

JP | March 23, 2009 11:53 PM

This weekend like almost all the weekends so far, nobody is a winner. It has been week after week of dreck. Most people have been wisely avoiding the theater because of it. The only exception has been "Watchmen". Which my explain why it has been the biggest grossing movie so far this year.

ecnirp07 | March 23, 2009 9:38 PM

He is a Paycheck Actor. It'll take Quentin to cast him in one of his movies to get some respect back.

Leave a comment



Advertisement

Advertisement