The Travers Take

Newer Older Latest

Bond Buzzkill: "Quantum of Solace" is a Letdown, but there is an Upper — "Casino Royale" on DVD

November 11, 2008 9:54 AM

Forget the DVD crap out today. Like you really need the unwatchable *Star Wars: The Clone Wars*. What you really need is *Casino Royale* from 2006, the first James Bond movie starring Daniel Craig. And you need it on Blu-ray with all the extras. Here's why. *Casino Royale* is a great Bond movie, up there with the best of them. *Quantum of Solace*, the followup which opens this weekend, is not great. In fact, it's a major letdown. But you are all going to see it. You know you will. For a few days you will pretend to love it. You will do this because you actually were jazzed by *Casino Royale* with Craig reinventing James Bond for the new century. But Craig's followup as 007 in *Quantum of Silly Titles* just doesn't cut it. Craig is still a primo hardass and the best Bond since Sean Connery. But the sizzle is gone from the movie. All you have to do is make some camparisons to *Casino Royale* and you'll see my point. So let us begin: **Too Much Action:** Bond seems to have come down with a serious case of Jason Bourne penis envy, leaping across rooftops from Bolivia to Haiti like a jug-eared Matt Damon. Put the blame on Marc Forster, a sensitive filmmaker (*Monster’s Ball, Finding Neverland*) who has no experience as an action director and appears to be seriously overcompensating. In *Casino Royale*, Martin Campbell – a real action man – stopped to savor the distractions in the script co-written by *Crash* Oscar winner Paul Haggis. And the opening action scene - strikingly shot in black-and-white - set up Bond as an MI6 agent who may be too much of a hothead to earn double-0 status and a license to kill. **Too Little Heat:** Pouty Ukrainian model Olga Kury­lenko is arguably the dullest Bond girl ever. Her character, Camille, treats 007 like he has an STD, and is so wrapped up in her own revenge plot we never get to know her. Compare her to luscious Eva Green as Vesper Lynd in *Casino Royale*. Vesper is a British treasury operative sent to stake Bond at the poker tables, and Green lifts her role to class-act status. Screenwriter Haggis contributes sly dialogue to a script that goes beyond kiss-kiss/bang-bang. A scene in which Bond and Vesper attempt to guess each other's past histories trumps its comic zing with romantic gravity. For instance: Bond: Miss Lynd, your beauty's a problem. You worry you won't be taken seriously. Lynd: Which one can say of any attractive woman with half a brain. Bond: True. But this one overcompensates by wearing slightly masculine clothing. Being more aggressive than her female colleagues. Which gives her a somewhat prickly demeanor, and ironically enough, makes it less likely for her to be accepted and promoted by her male superiors, who mistake her insecurities for arrogance. Lynd: By the cut of your suit, you went to Oxford or wherever. Naturally you think human beings dress like that. But you wear it with such disdain, my guess is you didn't come from money, and your school friends never let you forget it. Which means that you were at that school by the grace of someone else's charity: hence that chip on your shoulder. **Wussy Villain:** Dominic Greene, played by the vivid French actor Mathieu Amalric, starts well as the bug-eyed bad guy intent on control of the world's natural resources, but his evil duties are split with Bolivian general Medrano (Joaquín Cosio), whose perversities run to cliche. In the earlier film, there's Le Chiffre, played by the vivid Danish actor Mads Mikkelsen, a banker who launders money for terrorists and cries tears of blood when Bond takes him down over a card table at Montenegro's Casino Royale, where a test of character, not strength, will determine the eventual winner. **Crappy Theme Song:** I'm not saying that Chris Cornell's "You Know My Name" was much better than average in *Casino Royale*. But the new ditty, “Another Way to Die,” sung by Jack White and Alicia Keys, was a quantum of suckatude. What happened? See *Quantum* this weekend, grab hold of a *Casino* DVD, and get back to me. This is an argument worth having.
Newer Older Latest

9 Comments


Philbee | November 12, 2008 5:54 PM

I have not seen Q O S yet but it would be probably be next to impossible for it be as good as Casino Royale. Put me in that group of fans who thinks Timothy Dalton did a fine job as Bond.

Nathan | November 12, 2008 1:57 PM

Royale on blu-ray is a must, but you have to check out Kung Fu Panda (also on blu) it is freakin stunning in hi-def!

someone | November 12, 2008 11:04 AM

Quantum of Solace kicks mayor ass!

...and no, Im not preteding to "love it". you problem is that you expect another Casino Royale and its not the point here...cuz here he looks for payback...Vesper is no longer here so why you expect a funny Bond.

we agree...that song SUCKS!!! they should hvae used another Cornel song or maybe "Crack Hittler" by Faith No More...

john | November 12, 2008 9:01 AM

I dont see it being much of a letdown, its not like its as bad as some of the dalton/moore stuff. Just look what its done in UK totally wiped the floor with the rest of the crap out there.

John Satterfield-Doerr | November 12, 2008 6:59 AM

Why does everyone seem to hate the theme song? I'll admit that it's not as good as Cornell's but it's still a good interesting song.

Atlantic | November 12, 2008 6:09 AM

Well, it's definitely not as good as Casino Royale, and I think that some of the things Mr. Travers are correct, especially that there are too many action scenes and not enough scenes where Daniel Craig gets to shine (the scenes with Mathis in Q.o.S. are great).

(minor spoiler)
I don't think, however, that I'll stop thinking it's good in a couple of weeks. I think that it'll work better besides Casino Royale than standing alone. The two films together tell the story about Bond becoming 007. The ending to the story is really in this movie. That's when we first get the shot of Bond walking and shooting towards the camera for the first time (which comes at the beginning of other Bond films).

Two points: They should start using the Bond theme DURING the movies, and let's have more Jeffrey Wright next time!

Ryan | November 12, 2008 1:15 AM

Yes there is a lot of crap on DVD this week, and yes Casino Royale on blu-ray is probably your best bet, but don't count out Hellboy II of the new releases. I just picked it up today, has some cool special features with Del Toro on the set and is an overall cool movie, if people haven't seen it they should check it out.

Bo | November 11, 2008 7:43 PM

Right, where are the Bond girls and the flirts? There is only a quantum of that in the new film, if I remember correctly and that is when Bond asks the British brunette to help him find the stationary...?!

The argument for major "dropping of Bond constants" could be attributed to the fact, that it's a sequel, and for instance, Bond, James Bond, was already said in Casino Royale.

But Casino Royale anytime, anyplace over Quantum of Solace for me.

zois | November 11, 2008 4:42 PM

Couldn't agree more Travers. Quantum is already playing in Europe, and is, like you said, a bit of a letdown. Which doesn't necessarily mean it's bad. It was just very tough to follow the brilliance of Casino Royale. Maybe the third Craig installation will be a redeemer - but it will need a better villain, a "deeper" bondgirl and a smarter script. So the Bond top five stands like this if you allow only one actor to count:
1. Goldfinger - Connery
2. Casino Royale - Craig
3. On her majestys secret service (Lazenby - much underratted)
4. Goldeneye - Brosnan
5. For your eyes only - Moore

Sorry, Dalton

Leave a comment



Advertisement

Advertisement