Even if today's DVD releases were major—they're not unless watching Paris Hilton struggle to look alive in The Hottie & the Nottie strikes you as the ultimate symbol of creative striving —the pick of the week would still be the Two-Disc Special Edition of I'm Not There. Look, I know you didn't see this visionary work from director Todd Haynes in theaters. Just consider the film's paltry $3,728,430 gross (Iron Man made more than that in it's first five minutes at the box office). So it's time to grab this DVD—splendiferous in sound and image—and let it work you over. Haynes puts the music and the myth of Bob Dylan before us and, get this, never once mentions the name of the mesmeric changeling at his film's center. There's no need: Cover versions of Dylan songs occupy the movie like angels and demons doing battle at an exorcism. Not content with just one actor to portray Dylan in the act of inventing himself, Haynes hired six and hit the mega-jackpot with
Cate Blanchett, who burns through Haynes' head-trip odyssey like an illuminating torch. Blanchett's Oscar nominated performance (how she lost to Tilda Swinton in Michael Clayton will remain an enduring Academy mystery) is some kind of miracle. Playing the skinny, androgynous Dylan in his electric years — when his hair stood on end to match his fried nerves — Blanchett extends the possibilities of acting. Her toking, doping Dylan, named Jude, trades insights with gay poet Allen Ginsberg (David Cross), hits on an Edie Sedgwick-like socialite (Michelle Williams), rages against a prying journalist (Bruce Greenwood) and (surreal alert!) imagines gunning down the folkies at Newport '65 who booed when Dylan traded acoustic for electric. Even behind shades, Blanchett lets us in close to the trapped escape artist rattling his cage.
The downside of all the focus on Blanchett is the lack of attention to the film's other Dylans. The DVD helps us right the balance. Up first is the remarkable Marcus Carl Franklin, 14, Haynes' inspired choice to portray Dylan as a vagabond black boy named Woody (an hommage to Woody Guthrie). Then there's British actor Ben Whishaw, dandied up as Arthur in tribute to Dylan's admiration for the French symbolist poet Arthur Rimbaud. The reliably superb Christian Bale gets to manifest two sides of the master, as folk prophet Jack and later the Christian convert Pastor John, revving up the congregation with "Pressing On." The most problematic Dylan in terms of style shock, is Richard Gere as Billy, not just the outlaw Dylan played in Sam Peckinpah's Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid but the Dylan who went into exile in Woodstock, New York, after his 1966 motorcycle crash. The Gere sequence, opulently produced and featuring an irresistible rendering of "Goin' to Acapulco" by Jim James, may throw audiences off. But the Fellini-esque circus atmosphere is exactly where the film has been heading all along.
Still, the Dylan you'll want to reward with special attention belongs to Heath Ledger, who died less than two months after I'm Not There debuted in theaters. Ledger digs deep into the challenging role of Robbie, an actor who plays Dylan in a movie and whose relationship to the painter Claire (Charlotte Gainsbourg) mirrors Dylan's marriage to and divorce from Sarah Lownds. The DVD features a fitting tribute to Ledger that adds to the film's poignance regarding the pressures of celebrity.
The other bonus features are hit and miss. The deleted and extended scenes don't add much to the party, and the red-carpet premiere and on-set bloopers are Access Hollywood-style blather. But Haynes offers incisive audio commentary, we get to see Whishaw and Franklin audition, and you have to love the feature that accesses Dylan's lyrics as subtitles as the music is played.
Still, the kick of watching this DVD multiple times, aside from the power of the music and the images, is rating the actors playing Dylan. Blanchett takes pride of place in my book, followed by Ledger. What's your take?

Email
Stumble
AIM
Del.icio.us
DiggThis
Fark It!

- Portions of Album Content Provided by All Music Guide © 2009 All Media Guide, LLC.
steviegee | July 11, 2009 11:16 AM
If you like Whishaw, Brandon, you MUST see: PERFUME; BRIDESHEAD REVISITED.
You won't believe it's the same actor.
steviegee | July 11, 2009 11:14 AM
Probably the most under-rated movie of the year. Certainly the most intelligent and exciting piece of film-making and writing. Who cares which Dylan was the best? (We all had favorites - not the same thing. I loved Cate Blanchett's London Dylan, but that doesn't mean it was the best). The point was there were so many faces, and the writer-director used them with great fury and comic effect.
This is film-making that is as intelligent as it is imaginative. More than that, you can't ask.
mike | May 29, 2008 9:50 PM
Heath and just like the director his performance goes against the grain , outstanding performances all around but Heath steals the film!!!
Maggie | May 18, 2008 6:37 PM
I thought that Ben Whishaw had the most memorable performance. Although all of the actors in the movie were fantastic in their own manner, they all seemed like they were 'pretending' on some level. Maybe because most of the Dylans are well known names. However, Whishaw made it look easy. I remember leaving the theatre and talking about his performance for days. To me, he was Bob Dylan whereas Cate Blanchett, Heath Ledger, Christian Bale etc. were just impersonating.
Lennon | May 10, 2008 12:44 PM
now if only they had gotten The Man to play himself...or, even, play with himself....
brett | May 7, 2008 1:15 PM
also i believe im the only one who understands cate blanchett's performance was the only one that mimicked dylan mannerisms and didnt BECOME dylan.
the 65-66 period is so impressionable anyone can do what she did, and since she's the only woman playing him she gets the most attention.
ledger was miles better than her.
now, i love cate blanchett, but she just did the obvious in this movie.
brett | May 7, 2008 1:09 PM
1. i believe heath ledger's performance was easily the best as was his storyline. he deserved at least an oscar nod.
2. cate's gunning down the crowd wasn't so much an 'imagining' but what dylan actually felt like he was doing when he played there and then. hence, 'surreal'- not dreamed but seen as reality.
J | May 7, 2008 9:56 AM
This movie was so under appreciated. It's nice to see Peter give it some real attention.
Blanchett was the best I think and Bale was great in his limited screen Time. I was really impressed by Franklin as well. Whishaw too. They were ALL great, in my opinion.
Matt Vargas | May 7, 2008 9:28 AM
I loved this movie. Cate Blanchett was by far the
most entertaining and the hardest one to pull of.
But she did brilliantly. Her scenes with Bruce Greenwood are my favorite. Heath Ledger was great as "Robbie Clark" and watching him was bittersweet. The most underrated one was Ben Wishaw as the poet. He doesn't appear that much in the movie. But I loved his "rules on how to live a life in hiding" scene. Great cast. Great performances. Great movie.
auramac | May 7, 2008 4:25 AM
I almost envy one who's never heard of Dylan. You're gonna have an incredible time catching up! You're gonna be blown away- if you liked the film, wait'll you take a trip with the man.
Nathan T. | May 7, 2008 1:31 AM
The late Heath Ledger has the advantage of being in the most emotionally resonant scenes of "I'm Not There" (shout out also to the very talented Charlotte Gainsbourg as Claire). Being such a gorgeous, brainy, mindbender of a picture, the real sparks of feeling in the couple's deterioration are a major plus. Having noted that, I think only a contrarian fool would deny that Cate Blanchett gives one of the year's most dazzling performances. I can hardly think of a more beautiful woman than Blanchett and yet she nails everything about Dylan. It's uncanny.
Her Oscar mystery-she definitely deserved the prize-is really no mystery at all. "Michael Clayton" while good, is hardly on the level of Todd Hayne's film, but it's a solid, liberal minded picture that older Hollywood types could get behind. "I'm Not There" is challening and occasionally frustrating, thus the accessibility prize is given to "Michael Clayton" and it's red headed actress.
Mark Elliot Cullen | May 6, 2008 8:25 PM
I've got to say that Heath Ledger's performance really sticks to the gut. I can't help but think of his performance and character when I listen to 'Blood on the Tracks', it's infectious.
I think the major difference between the two best performances (Blanchett, Ledger) is that Blanchett's is a fantastic oscar worthy imitation of Dylan, but Ledger's is his own character. His character is part of Dylan, but undeniably a complete troubled performance.
I just wish we didn't have to sacrifice actor/actress screen time for the artistry of the commentary on identity, but in the end I think it's a good mix.
Savon | May 6, 2008 6:47 PM
My vote is for the late Heath Ledger. His scenes with Charlotte Gainsbourg were a highlight in the film. I second the cheers for Jim James. The sequence in which he appeared reminded me of Edgar Allan Poe and classic westerns at the same time. I was also pleased to see Bruce Greenwood in the film. Kudos to the casting director and the ensemble cast the Robert Altman casting award they received at the Independent Spirit Awards!
Jeff J | May 6, 2008 4:46 PM
I am so happy Travers mentioned this movie becuase it was the most underated movie from last year by far. While Blanchet was amazing, I found the sequences with Carl Marcus Franklin the most memerable. It did a great job in celebrating the man who's spirit was Bob Dylan for so long. It's also rare to see a performance by a child actor this good.
Nick | May 6, 2008 4:31 PM
I'm proud to say I DID see this in theatres, and I loved every minute of it. Cate Blanchett totally blew me away, but I think everybody else did a good job - and I didn't have any problems with the Gere sequences either. If I had any complaints, it's that for the most part Haynes didn't give Ben Whishaw enough time to shine. In any case, I've already bought the DVD and look forward to giving it many more views (although watching Heath will be a bittersweet experience).
joe | May 6, 2008 2:09 PM
terry,
it's a big world out there....
JasonTHX | May 6, 2008 1:24 PM
The DVD doesn't come out in Canada for another week! How frustrating. No theatre near would play it last fall either. I wasn't born in time to watch "8 1/2" on the big screen. I thought this would be the closest I'd get. Oh well. One more week. Also being a huge Dylanphile I would have enjoyed this on the big screen. Simple Twist of fate indeed.
Better news: I'm going to see The man himself perform on his B-Day, May 24th. Dylan birthday bash. In anticipation of "I'm Not There" I'm listening to dylan's most cinematic song "Visions Of Johanna".
Terry | May 6, 2008 12:20 PM
You never heard of Dylan until this film? please tell me youre joking!!!!
Brandon | May 6, 2008 11:26 AM
WHISHAW!!! I had never heard of the man until this film, and while I thoroughly enjoyed each artists take on a man who pushes the boundaries of eccentricity, Whishaw is easily the most spell-binding...I wish we could have seen more of him...