Review 1 of 2

thecollegedropout writes:

4of 5 Stars

i know rolling stone mag got flack for their rating of this album, but i actually think it's a step back to form in a way. it's not blue album or pinkerton, even though it seems like a mix mash of the two albums. it's catchy, that's for sure, and i think it's about as good as the green album. the album is also the most sing along album they've ever released, maybe even more so then the blue album. it's unfairly harshly judged, because it's actually a very good album, even though the lyrics definitely need work.

Jun 13, 2008 22:01:51

Review 2 of 2

KevinRules writes:

1of 5 Stars

I can't believe the editors at Rolling Stone read this review and allowed it to be published. Make Believe is, by any and all standards, a disturbingly bad album rife with cliched lyrics and nonexistent hooks. "We Are All On Drugs" may be the worst single released in the new century, and the "confessional" lyrics of "Pardon Me" and "Peace" are so irritatingly straightforward that an 8th grader could've written them. Weezer either needs to get back on track, or they need to break up and spare us the indignity of purchasing another half-assed album.

Jun 28, 2007 08:16:01