The Dandy Warhols: Earth To The Dandy Warhols : Music Reviews : Rolling Stone

Album Reviews

Earth to the Dandy Warhols finds the Portland, Oregon, rockers seriously indulging their artier side for the second album in a row — perhaps they've accepted that their commercial moment passed with the 2004 documentary Dig!, which followed them from obscurity to major-label success. Or maybe they still covet the weirdo genius accorded their buddies and Dig! co-stars, the Brian Jonestown Massacre. Whatever the case, this vaguely space-themed, quasi-psychedelic disc is a misstep: The melodies are buried in electric goo, and frontman Courtney Taylor-Taylor's sharp wit is tough to decipher under an assortment of buzzes and drones. Sometimes the band's strong tune sense breaks through: On "Love Song" — which features guitar work from Mark Knopfler and banjo from the Heartbreakers' Mike Campbell — the Dandys turn out pretty jangle rock. But "Welcome to the Third World," which mashes up airy keyboards, a disco-funk groove and Taylor-Taylor's dragueur sing-speak, almost literally seems like two songs playing at the same time. Too often, Earth sounds like the Dandys have too many toys — or maybe too many ideas.