Album Reviews
So much of the new country-rock thrown out today is dirge-quality serious. The faces of the artists show the fearful haunted faces of the Civil War. It's probably a reflection of the times, but someone could get the idea that Americans were a grieving, introspective and shattered people. Most of this music is good, but if its purpose is to make a more relevant and "real" American music, then it must show, also, the open and exuberant quality that has marked American music since it began.
Uncle Charlie and His Dog Teddy is a Grade A movie in this direction. The Nitty Gritty Dirt Band has cut a varied and vital album with both a sense of history and a smiling face. In theme, and often in sound, it reaches back to that form of Appalachian music that pretty much ceased as an indigenous form long about the death of Charlie Poole (1935) or shortly thereafter. With the emergence of modern country music, this kind of boisterous, nasal and downright charming music was relegated to providing incidental music for Hoot Gibson.
This isn't the first time it's been reanimated, but is one of the better jobs. Actually, Uncle Charlie contains about half a dozen musical styles, none of them of musicological purity. But all the cuts, bits and codas, together with the Uncle Charlie interview, come out a cohesive country comfort.
First, let me tell you about Uncle Charlie. He died a few years ago about age seventy-four at his country home. But he left this tape wherein he coughs up a little history and sings and plays a couple of songs. His dog, Teddy, sings "Rugged Old Cross" (yup, he does). They set the tone.
The Dirt Band does a couple of traditional, instrumental things like "Chicken Reel" and "Clinch Mountain Backstep." They're full and vigorous.
Better, though, are the contemporary songs done with an old-timey flavor. Generally, this sort of thing is about as convincing as an English Pub in Pasadena and often cheapens the material. Here, it enhances it.
For instance, there are two fine Mike Nesmith songs, "Some of Shelley's Blues" and "Propinquity" that are just right for the light treatment dealt by the banjo-rock sound. Randy Newman's "Living Without You" is sad without being heavy. Likewise, "Mr. Bojangles" comes away a better song. A beautiful song, but usually sung so wistfully that the genuine pathos is destroyed. The Dirt Band makes it both sad and amusing.
They do some straight rock. A Buddy Hollyish "Rave On" and an original, "House at Pooh Corner," that in spite of its story, doesn't cloy.
One of the Dirt Band's strongest points is instrumentation. Each of the five members plays from three to six instruments, all without that boring virtuosity that mars many a modern stab at country. They have a great deal of life, even on their bluegrass stuff, and none of it slavishly follows anything. One cut, in fact, "Opus 36" is one of the most original things I've heard on the banjo.
There are cuts that drag some, and after five or six times you'd wish that Uncle Charlie had died young, but these aren't serious defects. This isn't a great record, but it doesn't try to be. It's an enjoyable record. It might even remind you that Americans could be really enjoyable if they weren't so dangerous. (RS 69)
ALEX DUBRO
(Posted: Oct 29, 1970)
Click the play button.
Register or enter your username and password.
Let the music play!
It's FREE.
- Some Of Shelly's Blues
- Prodigal's Return
- The Cure
- Travelin' Mood
- Chicken Reel
- Yukon Railroad
- Livin' Without You
- Clinch Mountain Backstep
- Rave On
- Billy In The Low Ground
- Jesse James
- Uncle Charlie Interview
- Mr. Bojangles
- Opus 36
- Santa Rosa
- Propinquinty
- Uncle Charlie
- Randy Lynn Rag
- House At Pooh Corner
- Swanee River
- Uncle Charlie Interview #2 / The End / Spanish Fandango
- Mississippi Rain (Bonus Track)
- What Goes On (Bonus Track)
![]() |
Advertisement
More CD Reviews
-
Wilco
Wilco -
Rob Thomas
Cradlesong -
The Mars Volta
Octahedron -
Regina Spektor
Far -
Jonas Brothers
Lines, Vines and Trying Times -
Danger Mouse
Danger Mouse and Sparklehorse Present: Dark Night of the Soul -
Moby
Wait for Me -
Dinosaur Jr.
Farm -
Black Eyed Peas
The E.N.D. (The Energy Never Dies) -
Levon Helm
Electric Dirt
Hear it Now
View
Email
Stumble
AIM
Del.icio.us
DiggThis
Fark It!





- Portions of Album Content Provided by All Music Guide © 2009 All Media Guide, LLC.