Review 1 of 2

radioheadthegreat writes:

Not Rated

Honestly i dont understand all the fuss...why is everybody recommend this album as great? I have this album, i try to listened to it everyday, and i dont see why this album can be consider good.

May 25, 2007 03:20:09

Review 2 of 2

shadowbox77 writes:

4of 5 Stars

I just wanted to say that it would help if the review for Neon Bible was actually with the album art and tracklisting of Neon Bible instead of Arcade Fire's first EP. Hopefully someone at Rolling Stone will figure this out and change it. But this mistake is a telling example of how haphazardly some of the magazine's reviews are done. This album is surely a four-star album especially when it is put next to many other albums the magazine has given four stars to (Deerhoof and The Good, the Bad, and the Queen to name a couple recent ones). Although everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, I feel it would help the readers of Rolling Stone if the magazine strove for a higher level of consistency in their reviews. Too many great albums have gotten mediocre ratings while others get much higher ratings than they deserve. I hope that when they fix the page this review is on, they fix the rating as well.

Feb 20, 2007 12:12:11